On being right – or wrong

Once more www.TED.com has come up with a great resource in the form of a talk by Kathryn Schulz On Being Wrong.  This reached me via Stuart Reid* who commented: 


There is quite a lot in this TED talk from Kathryn Schulz that helps to explain why the ‘unilateral control model’ is so powerful.  Schulz has a view that one reason why we care so much about being wrong is that we often feel that if we are wrong there is something wrong with us – so we insist instead that we are right.  And she also makes the point well that feeling we are right is often not a reliable guide to what’s going on out there in the real world.

Leaders who are attached to always being right are easy to spot.  They rarely ask for input from those they lead in order to form a plan and even when they do it’s their own ideas that prevail.  They have people reporting to them – sometimes very senior people – who think twice before putting forward an idea for fear of the public humiliation that will follow.  They think their staff are rubbish (“they have no ideas to offer at all”) and they may overlook the fact that some very talented people come and go from their watch.  They are often disappointed with the outcomes from their staff and rarely take responsibility.  Of course, it’s not just leaders who have this kind of experience – it’s colleagues, spouses, parents and children…

I want to add that, in our culture, this is not uncommon.  Take a moment to notice when you have wanted to be right even though you knew you were wrong, when you were really hard on yourself or on someone else for the things that didn’t go to plan, when you were afraid of the consequences of a mistake or escaped into your head to think about it instead of to feel it.

How much compassion do you have for your own mistakes?  And for the mistakes of others?

*And yes, if you follow Stuart’s link, you’ll find all sorts of additional treasures to explore.

2 thoughts on “On being right – or wrong

  1. I love this blog Dorothy. I had a wonderful moment last week when someone said something to me that angered me. I noticed I was angry and that I thought I was 'right' and he was 'wrong'. I tried to step out of the anger but noticed I could both see it and was stuck in it. I suspended my response but with every sinnew in my body wanting to say what I wanted to say. Walked, breathed and observed myself. Calmed down, gained perspective, was generous in thought about what the person had said and let it all drift away. Actually I was not 'right'. There are a range of possibilities. My anger was just a thought and I let it drift back in to the mist from which it had so forcefully come.

    Len

  2. Hi Len

    Thank you so much for sharing your experiences and yes, I have those moments, too – isn't anger so compelling? At least in the short term.

    I've started to explore what lies underneath the anger – so much conditioning around placing others' needs ahead of my own, for example, that it's hard to say to myself (let alone others) that I have needs that aren't being met right now. It's so much easier to justify myself by placing myself in the right… I guess you could say that given my conditioning being angry is a highly adaptive way to meet my needs!

    And yes, underneath the anger sit my unmet needs. I'm taking a moment to cherish them right now.

    Dorothy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *